I will be truthful. I am still not sure how I feel about this whole self publishing argument. I agree with both sides and I always assumed that the day would come when self-publishing would simply be an accepted medium for fiction. I have given this more thought than usual as of late for reasons that I will get into a bit later on in this post. But for now, here are my own thoughts on both sides of the self-publishing coin.
A few weeks ago, a poetry editor tweeted a pretty funny comment…a comment that was both humorous and truthful: The words “poetry” and “self published”, when used together, make me cringe. And this leads to the most obvious con to the self publishing argument. Anyone can do it. The mother who thinks her 8 year old’s poems are so cute and insightful that other mothers will want to read them. She types the kids poems up, posts them up on LuLu and BAM, an 8 year old has a book of collected poems published. The goth kid that is a little into Marilyn Manson (a trip to the mall this weekend proved to me that these do still exist) writes a few verses about the blackness that is his soul and how every emotion he feels is an endless chasm of torment and death. Go online, take about 15 minutes to walk through the necessary steps, and BOOM, he’s a published author.
Yikes.
On the other hand, what about those very unique stories that the bigger publishing houses and agents have turned their noses up at and the smaller houses didn’t want to take the gamble on? If it weren’t for self publishing, I feel that quite a few good books would have never seen the light of day. Some basic Google research will give you some pretty impressive numbers.
I also understand that to be a “self-published” author, there is a degree of “shamness” attached to you and your book. Authors that have been published by traditional means see you as an inferior. In most circuits and stores, self-published books are scoffed at and not taken seriously (unless the author can get a power-boosted marketing campaign behind the book and even then, the chances are slim).
So, really, I just don’t see how one can make such a decision about self- publishing. I would love to see an experiment where a well established author self publishes a book under a pseudonym just to see what happens.
Anyway, I have been thinking hard about this for the past few weeks for a particular reason. I have compiled a collection of my work and have been shopping it around for a while. It’s been very hard to get anyone interested and the rejection letters seem to have the same reasoning…it’s just too diverse.
The collection, aptly titled Debris, has a bit of everything. Mainstream short stories, short stories of 9,000 words, flash pieces of 350 words and poetry (some only 10 lines, others 3 pages). Also, while 75% of the work is horror, the rest is simply mainstream fiction. So it’s been very hard to sell this concept to any genre publisher.
So that’s where I started think of self-publishing. And while I still haven’t’ made a decision, it’s something I give more and more thought to each day.
So what are your opinions? Self-publishing: good or bad. And would you even consider purchasing a collection like this if it were self-published?